A+ R A-

A Black Life is Worth Less than a $50 Box of Cigars?

E-mail Print PDF

Share this article with a friend

(NNPA) Under other circumstances one could simply ridicule the explanations offered by the Ferguson police regarding the killing of Michael Brown. To suggest that the killing was the result of the alleged theft of a $50 box of cigars or, for that matter, an angry exchange in connection with jaywalking, defies belief. To think about the number of people in this country who, in their youth, engaged in some degree of shoplifting or who have jaywalked suggests that there would need to be mass executions on a scale never before seen in the history of humanity.

Clearly, the killing had to do with neither the alleged theft nor alleged jaywalking. It had to do with power and life. The power was the power of a White-dominated police department to assert its total control over the activities of a population that has been largely disenfranchised from a supposed democracy. In that sense, Michael Brown was at the wrong place at the wrong time. That said, while circumstances could have resulted in Brown not having been at that precise location, the reality with which African Americans are all too familiar is that we are all potentially Michael Browns. There are no safety zones; there are no no-shooting zones in the USA when it comes to Black America. It is that point that many Black youth are attempting to capture with photos, tweets and slogans.

The killing was also about life. What White people in the U.S. need to ask themselves is whether there are any circumstances in their respective communities where the killing of a young White man for either allegedly stealing cigars or for getting into an argument with an officer regarding jaywalking would be tolerated. If the answer is “no,” then the follow up question is simple: Why should it be acceptable in African American communities?

The answer is implicit in the reality for African Americans throughout U.S .history: There is not an equivalent value on African American and White life in this society. There is not only the presumption of guilt, when African Americans have an encounter with the police, but an additional presumption that the police are justified in utilizing any means available against a Black alleged criminal, even if no crime has been committed.

Ferguson brought to my mind Gaza and the way in which Palestinian life has no value for the Israeli government. Three Jewish Israeli boys were brutally kidnapped and murdered and the Israeli political establishment decided to unite to punish all Palestinians, and especially those in Gaza, without a shred of evidence. No matter how many Palestinian civilians are killed, it is justified by the Israeli government on the grounds of their need to punish. What is implicit is the math: the deaths of three Jewish Israelis are compensated for by the deaths of more than a 1,900 Palestinians. When the proportions are that extreme the bottom line is simple: Palestinian life holds no value.

Oppression and tyranny can continue and gain popular support when those who are oppressed are deprived of the recognition of their humanity. When African Americans are presumed to be dangerous criminals or when Palestinians are presumed to be murderers, then there is no need for a trial. There is only need for an execution…and be done with it.

Bill Fletcher, Jr. is a racial justice, labor and global justice activist and writer. Follow him on Facebook and at www.billfletcherjr.com.

Add comment

By using our comment system, you agree to not post profane, vulgar, offensive, or slanderous comments. Spam and soliciting are strictly prohibited. Violation of these rules will result in your comments being deleted and your IP Address banned from accessing our website in the future. Your e-mail address will NOT be published, sold or used for marketing purposes.

Security code


0 # M. Everett 2014-11-24 20:22
Hate! That is what this country is all about is hate
-1 # C. Hanley 2014-09-01 05:11
This question is ludicrous due to the fact that a man in NY was killed by a policeman by a choke hold for selling single (loose) cigarettes. Obviously, the value of a Black person's worth is an irrelevant questions. To say the least, the policing war against Black & Brown citizens is "on" across America. It doesn't take much for black or brown Americans to lose their lives at the hands of a police officer who is hired to "protect and serve".
0 # patm013 2014-09-01 03:27
black America is its own worst enemy. as you and other black leaders bash whites, young black men continue to commit murder at an alarming rate. 500 murders in Chicago last year! what sayeth yee? NOTHING! NADA! ZIP! ZILCH! Michael brown? how about megan boken? Delbert belton? colleen ritzer? nick trapuzzano? Christopher lane? and how about the case of channon Christian and Christopher newsome? what those 5 creeps did to them was inhuman! yet again, you and every single black person says nothing. it doesn't count. wonder why whites profile? this is why. a white man is 50 times more likely to be murdered by a black man than a black man by a white man. do you know this or just ignore it? young black men are about 5% of the population and committed 51% of all murders. that's more than the other 95% of the population put together. profiling? why don't you grow some gonads and tell black men to stop killing people! maybe then, just maybe, we'll stop profiling!
0 # M. Everett 2014-11-24 20:23
Sure! As soon as you people stop raping little boys, shooting up schools

BVN National News Wire